• Banner 3
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 1

Welcome to Pelino's Pasta

Pelino's Pasta, located in Columbus, Ohio, offers an exquisite fine dining experience centered around authentic Italian cuisine. Renowned for its ever-evolving menu, guests can savor dishes like squash and hazelnut pasta and their signature Cacio e Pepe, served table-side from a cheese wheel. The ambiance is warm and welcoming, enhanced by knowledgeable staff who provide detailed menu insights, ensuring a rich dining experience. From delectable antipasti to handcrafted dolci like tiramisu, each dish reflects a blend of tradition and creativity. Pelino's is not just a meal; it's a journey into the heart of Italian culinary artistry.

LOCATIONS
  • Pelino's Pasta
    245 King Ave, Columbus, OH 43201, United States
    245 King Ave, Columbus, OH 43201, United States Hotline: +1 614-849-6966

Welcome to Pelino's Pasta, a vibrant culinary gem nestled in Columbus, Ohio. Located at 245 King Ave, this Italian eatery has quickly garnered a reputation for its exquisite offerings and exceptional dining experience. The atmosphere is both inviting and sophisticated, making it the perfect destination for both special occasions and casual meals.

Pelino's Pasta brings authentic Italian flavors to life through a thoughtfully curated menu that changes with the seasons. Each dish captures the essence of Italy with a modern twist. From the popular Cacio e Pepe, served tableside with a dramatic cheese wheel presentation, to the innovative Spaghetti e Zucca featuring squash and hazelnuts, there's something for every palate. The Paccheri Alla Genovese showcases the depth of Italian cuisine, and the rich Gnocchi Di Ricotta is a must-try.

The dining experience is enhanced by a knowledgeable staff dedicated to ensuring that each guest feels cared for and informed. As Sarah Bugner noted, the waiters provide detailed insights into the menu, making it easy for newcomers to navigate the diverse selections. This attentiveness contributes significantly to the overall enjoyment, making first-time experiences like Jacob Luckring's truly memorable.

For those looking to indulge further, Pelino's delightful Tiramisu and the opportunity to pair fine Italian wines with each meal elevate the gastronomic adventure. A visit here is not just about the food; it is about the stories shared by the staff, including insights into the ingredients and their origins, which Sophia Hammonds found enchanting during her Valentine's outing.

While Pelino's Pasta boasts a narrow focus—specializing primarily in Italian cuisine and fine wines—the dedication to authenticity and quality is commendable. The absence of cocktails allows for a streamlined experience, emphasizing a deep appreciation for classic Italian wine pairings, expertly curated by the knowledgeable sommelier.

Overall, Pelino's Pasta provides a unique culinary journey that captivates its patrons with every dish. It's a place where traditional Italian cuisine marries modern flair, making it worthy of a visit. Whether you're a seasoned food lover or new to the world of Italian dining, Pelino's is sure to impress. Prepare for an exquisite meal that will leave you eagerly anticipating your next visit.

START YOUR REVIEW OF Pelino's Pasta
Sarah Bugner
Sarah Bugner

From the January menu (theme was Best of 2024) the squash and hazelnut pasta was my favorite. The cacio e Pepe tossed in the cheese wheel table-side is also very good and a classic menu item. Highly recommend the wine pairing too! Portion sizes are not large but not so small that a 3 course meal isn’t enough, though if you’re hungrier I’d recommend the 4 course option. The waiters do a full menu run-through before you order so you know how everything is prepared (I.e. what all of the Italian words are) which is great so you don’t have to ask or secretly google anything. The staff are all super nice and the hostess that night (who might be the owner?) is from Italy and knows a lot about the wine list which is an impressive selection of Italian glasses from all throughout Italy (I was particularly surprised about how many options there were from less common Italian regions, white wines in particular). I will definitely be returning to try more menu items and wines!

Jacob Luckring
Jacob Luckring

This was my first experience with true fine dining and it was awesome. Like I’ve said I’ve never been to a place like this that changes their menu. The waitress was extremely nice and literally explained in full detail the entire menu. Food was delicious and timely. Just an overall great experience.

M. William Martin
M. William Martin

Best Italian food my wife and I have had in Columbus. We lived in the New York and North Jersey area for years, and this is the only restaurant in Columbus we’ve been to (so far) that could hold its own against the best of North Jersey. We got the Ricotta Gnocchi, Spaghetti e Zucca, and Paccheri alla Genovese. Each of these dishes were fantastic in their own right. Combined, they made for a fabulous dinner. And get the tiramisu! The Cacio e Pepe was also very popular, we so the cheese wheel roll out to several different tables throughout the night. We dined at the bar. Service-wise, the bartender was excellent. And he gave us a full tour of the menu prior to ordering, which was nice since it was our first time here (but not our last!). We also ordered a bottle of wine with dinner. The sommelier had a deep knowledge of their wine list and was helpful in finding a bottle of wine that was right for our evening. We went with the Ghemme from Bianchi Giuseppe. Would recommend, but make sure to get a decanter and let it breathe. A note- they have no cocktails, just wine. This may not be for everyone, but we appreciated that they kept their focus narrow, yet deep. Don’t be afraid to ask the somm for help, you’re in good hands.

Sophia Hammonds
Sophia Hammonds

Came to celebrate Valentine's Day and it was our first time at the restaurant. We opted for the full tasting menu and we were not disappointed. Every dish was savory and delicious. Alicia, our server, was unassuming and intentional in her care of our space. Each dish arrived with a story of historical and cultural significance, we were utterly transported. Such an unpretentious vibe for all the impeccabilities being served! The owner Christina (sp?) came by to greet us and shared with us her family's love and roots in the culture and cuisine. It was an overall 10/10 experience.

P Carpenter
P Carpenter

The bar chair is a little low compared to the booth height. Food was great. Nice to get away from Italian with an over use of tomato and cheese. Unique dishes. Parking stinks, but what are you going to do? Check it out!

Emily Johnson
Emily Johnson

My coworkers and I did a tasting menu here and the service was probably the best I’ve experienced in Columbus. The staff presenting each course was extremely knowledgeable, our glasses were never empty, and the entire experience was seamless. Such a treat to have this little gem of a restaurant in Columbus!

Sean Campbell
Sean Campbell

Sean with Offline - BEST TIRAMISU !! Now this was an upscale restaurant in the heart of Italian village. The food was made fresh and it was very elegant and upscale. Portions were a little small but they used quality ingredients. We heard the menu changes monthly, and the set up is you go with a 3, 4, or 7 course dinner selecting from different options. (7courses is set I believe). they also have wine pairings for each course but we didn’t participate because of dry January :/

Allie brown
Allie brown

Every time I come here they always have it down! Excellent food and very well prepared my only complaint would be a bit pricey for the portion sizes but other than that you can really see that the chefs put their hearts into this I would say top 3 in Columbus for sure!